Arizona senator Kyrsten Sinema leaves Democrats to become independent – live

Sinema: independence ‘won’t change my work in Senate’

Kyrsten Sinema’s bombshell defection from the Democratic party will have far-reaching consequences as Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer attempts to plot a course through the upcoming Congress.

In her op-ed in the Arizona Republic on Friday announcing the move, the enigmatic Sinema sought to assure voters that “becoming an independent won’t change my work in the Senate; my service to Arizona remains the same”.

But the free-spirited politician, the first openly bisexual woman in the Senate, says she considers the bipartisan system in the US “broken” and won’t pledge her support to either party:

Americans are told that we have only two choices – Democrat or Republican – and that we must subscribe wholesale to policy views the parties hold, views that have been pulled further and further toward the extremes.

When politicians are more focused on denying the opposition party a victory than they are on improving Americans’ lives, the people who lose are everyday Americans.

Not that she fully supported the Democratic agenda in Joe Biden’s first two years in office, often teaming up with centrist West Virginia senator Joe Manchin to stall key parts of the president’s agenda.

Yet the statement will still alarm party leaders, who thought they had secured a 51-49 majority on Tuesday when Raphael Warnock won re-election in Georgia.

In a natural extension of my service since I was first elected to Congress, I have joined the growing numbers of Arizonans who reject party politics by declaring my independence from the broken partisan system in Washington and formally registering as an Arizona Independent. 1/3 pic.twitter.com/jUQHAeuxym

— Kyrsten Sinema (@kyrstensinema) December 9, 2022

Unlike Bernie Sanders (Vermont) and Angus King (Maine) who caucus with the Democrats, Sinema as an independent – unshackled by the Democratic party whip – will be an altogether different beast, whatever she says about her behavior not changing.

It’s not even clear she will retain her office on the Democratic side of the chamber. Or if she will re-election in 2024, something she says she won’t address yet.

It also restores “outsized influence in the Democratic caucus” to Manchin, according to Politico, which sat down for a 45-minute chat with Sinema this morning. Manchin was the main thorn in Biden’s side from within when the Senate was split 50-50.

We’re expecting to hear much more reaction today about the stunning news, including how Schumer intends to press on with committee assignments for the upcoming congress.

Read more:

Key events

Chuck Schumer, the Democratic Senate majority leader, has issued a brief statement on the decision by Arizona’s Kyrsten Sinema to sit in the chamber as an independent.

He says she will keep her committee assignments, which he doesn’t really have a choice about if Democrats are to retain a semblance of control:

Senator Sinema informed me of her decision to change her affiliation to Independent. She asked me to keep her committee assignments and I agreed.

Kyrsten is independent; that’s how she’s always been. I believe she’s a good and effective Senator and am looking forward to a productive session in the new Democratic majority Senate.

We will maintain our new majority on committees, exercise our subpoena power, and be able to clear nominees without discharge votes.

Meanwhile, The Hill has been collating reports that the 6 January House panel looking into Donald Trump’s insurrection is also considering criminal referrals, for Trump and at least four of the ex-president’s team.

They are Mark Meadows, the former White House chief of staff; John Eastman, a conservative lawyer; Jeffrey Clark, a former justice department official; and Rudy Giuliani, Trump’s one-time personal attorney.

Mark Meadows. Photograph: Alex Brandon/AP

All four were involved in plotting or executing Trump’s scheme to try to overturn his defeat by Joe Biden, the panel believes, and is considering whether to recommend them to the justice department for criminal investigation or charges.

“The committee has not officially decided whom to refer for prosecution and for what offenses,” CNN reported, citing anonymous sources, and says others could also be considered.

The Guardian reported Tuesday that criminal referrals were imminent from the January 6 committee, but this is the first time these names have been reported. Representatives of the panel would not comment.

You can read The Hill’s report here.

While we’ve been occupied this morning with Kyrsten Sinema’s defection and Brittney Griner’s homecoming, we haven’t taken our eye off Donald Trump’s legal peril, and developments with the investigations into his insurrection and mishandling of classified documents. Here’s the Guardian’s Hugo Lowell on the latest:

The US justice department is seeking a top federal judge to hold Donald Trump’s political office in contempt of court for not fully complying with a grand jury subpoena issued in May demanding the return of all classified documents in its possession, according to a source familiar with the matter.

The department in recent weeks asked the chief US district court judge for the District of Columbia, Beryl Howell, to hold Trump’s office in contempt after prosecutors were unable to get the former president’s lawyers to designate a custodian of records to certify all records were returned.

New: Confirming that DOJ is seeking a federal judge to hold Trump’s office in contempt of court for not fully complying with May grand jury subpoena seeking return of classified docs, per source familiar — matching WaPo

— Hugo Lowell (@hugolowell) December 8, 2022

Howell has not ruled on the matter, which remains under seal. But the move, earlier reported by the Washington Post, significantly raises the stakes for Trump as he stares down a criminal investigation into unauthorized retention of national security information and obstruction of justice.

The issue is to do with the Trump legal team’s reluctance to designate a custodian of records to certify that Trump is no longer in possession of any documents marked classified and thus in compliance with the subpoena that demanded the return of all such government records, the source said.

If the Trump legal team could not find someone to certify under oath that all documents bearing classified markings had been returned, the department is said to have communicated, it would seek a judicial sanction.

The contempt action is understood to be focused on Trump’s office because the subpoena, issued on 11 May, sought the return of all documents and writings “in the custody of Donald J Trump and/or the Office of Donald J Trump” bearing classification markings.

Read the full story:

As we’ve mentioned Republican criticism of Joe Biden for trading basketball star Brittney Griner for convicted arms dealer Viktor Bout, here’s Florida senator Marco Rubio’s considered opinion:

“We have to recognize, even as we’re happy an American’s coming home, it does incentivize the taking of more Americans,” he told reporters on Friday morning.

The theme from Republicans seems to be that the exchange was a very poor deal for Biden. Even Adam Kinzinger of Illinois, who angered his party by joining the January 6 committee, weighed in.

Although Biden stressed on Thursday the deal was essentially “get Griner or get nobody”, Kinzinger appeared furious that Paul Whelan, an American detained in Russia for four years on espionage charges, was left behind:

What about retired marine who has been unjustly detained for years, Paul Whelan? Surely an arms dealer is worth two innocent people? @POTUS

— Adam Kinzinger #fella (@AdamKinzinger) December 8, 2022

Not so fast, says Tristan Snell, a political analyst and lawyer who helped prosecute the Trump University scam while at the New York attorney general’s office. As president, Snell says, Trump secured the release of a Taliban leader, Abdul Ghani Baradar, for… absolutely nobody.

In late 2018, Trump released Abdul Ghani Baradar, one of the top leaders of the Taliban, along with 5000 other Taliban fighters, in exchange for… *checks notes*… nobody.

— Tristan Snell (@TristanSnell) December 9, 2022

Russia’s president Vladimir Putin has said more prisoner swaps are possible after Moscow yesterday released American basketball star Brittney Griner in exchange for arms dealer Viktor Bout, the Associated Press reports.

“Everything is possible,” Putin said, when asked in an interview if another such exchange could happen. “We aren’t refusing to continue this work in the future.”

Still detained in Russia is Paul Whelan, an American corporate security executive who is facing espionage charges. Republicans criticized Joe Biden for agreeing to a deal that did not include Whelan, a former marine, while the president pledged to continue working for his release.

A major question facing Democrats is whether Kyrsten Sinema will continue to caucus with them in the Senate.

While they don’t strictly need her vote to control the chamber, they were counting on her to push their majority from its current 50-50 split – where vice-president Kamala Harris breaks ties – to an outright 51 seat majority, which would make getting their agenda through the Senate easier.

The senator dodged a question about that in an interview with Phoenix’s KTAR radio station, while suggesting she’d caucus with neither party but still remain on committees:

Sinema says who she will caucus with is an “important question” but a “DC type of question”

Says again she expects to keep committee assignments – and thinks she can do that w/o necessarily caucusing with either party

That would be a unique arrangement.

— Rick Klein (@rickklein) December 9, 2022

Kyrsten Sinema distinguished herself among senators for avoiding reporters and rarely granting interviews over the last two years. She reversed that trend today, speaking to Politico and writing an op-ed in the Arizona Republic.

She also spoke about her decision in an interview with CNN:

Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (I-AZ) tells CNN’s @jaketapper she’s leaving the Democratic Party: “A growing number of Arizonans and people like me just don’t feel like we fit neatly into one party’s box or the other.” pic.twitter.com/T4EighvBLn

— The Recount (@therecount) December 9, 2022

Kyrsten Sinema has infuriated Democrats to such a degree that a group had already organized to challenge her in the party’s primary.

That won’t be happening since the senator has departed the party, but the group, aptly named Primary Sinema, has pledged to fight on:

It’s official: Kyrsten Sinema has left the Democratic Party.

In some ways, our job just got easier. She’s not running in a Democratic primary because she knew she’d lose. So now, we’re going to beat her in the general election. Arizonans deserve better. (1)

— Primary Sinema Project (@PrimarySinemaAZ) December 9, 2022

We launched this effort 15 months ago to educate the public about the ways Kyrsten Sinema has failed Arizonans, obstructed progress, and caved to special interests. Arizonans deserve a Senator who cares about them, not special interests like Wall Street and Big Pharma. (2/3)

— Primary Sinema Project (@PrimarySinemaAZ) December 9, 2022

Sinema just told us what we already knew: she’s not a Democrat and she’s out for herself.

Our name, Primary Sinema, will be updated soon to reflect that this is now a general election effort. The work continues, and in some ways, just became even more important. #DefeatSinema

— Primary Sinema Project (@PrimarySinemaAZ) December 9, 2022

White House expects to ‘continue to work successfully’ with Sinema

White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre has weighed in on senator Kyrsten Sinema’s departure from the Democratic party, noting her support of several of Joe Biden’s priorities and pledging to continue working with her.

“Senator Sinema has been a key partner on some of the historic legislation President Biden has championed over the last 20 months, from the American Rescue Plan to the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, from the Inflation Reduction Act to the CHIPS and Science Act, from the PACT Act to the Gun Safety Act to the Respect for Marriage Act, and more,” Jean-Pierre said.

“We understand that her decision to register as an independent in Arizona does not change the new Democratic majority control of the Senate, and we have every reason to expect that we will continue to work successfully with her.”

Women’s basketball star Brittney Griner is back on American soil after yesterday’s prisoner exchange with arms dealer Viktor Bout:

The American basketball star Brittney Griner returned to the US early on Friday after being freed in a high-profile prisoner exchange from nearly 10 months in detention in Russia.

The deal, in which she was swapped for the Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout, secured the release of the most prominent American detained abroad and achieved a top goal for Joe Biden. But Washington failed to win freedom for another US citizen, Paul Whelan, who has been jailed for nearly four years.

Griner is a two-time Olympic gold medallist, Baylor University All-American and Phoenix Mercury pro basketball star. Her status as an openly gay Black woman, locked up in a country where authorities have been hostile to the LBGTQ community, injected racial, gender and social dynamics into her legal saga and brought unprecedented attention to the population of wrongful detainees.

Sinema’s departure from the Democratic party is less about frustrating their ability to run the Senate for the next two years, and more about protecting her own position in Arizona, Semafor reports.

She’s unpopular enough with Democrats in the state that she was widely expected to face a primary in 2024. But now that she’s out of the party, that primary won’t happen. Instead, Democrats are going to face the tough decision of whether to run a candidate against her – and risk splitting their voters and losing the seat to the GOP – or accept that she’s their best bet, even if she isn’t actually in the party.

Here’s more from Semafor:

There are/were at least three ongoing campaigns to primary Sinema with Rep. Ruben Gallego, which just became impossible. Doesn’t affect D majority, does prevent AZ Dems from replacing her https://t.co/ixxC7kFwPt

— David Weigel (@daveweigel) December 9, 2022

I woke up on the west coast so was initially confused by some bad analysis that pretended this risked the balance of power. It doesn’t – it’s a gordian knot-cutting political tactic that nullifies the biggest threat to Sinema’s reelection, a primary against Phoenix’s congressman.

— David Weigel (@daveweigel) December 9, 2022

One more thing: We don’t know how Dems play this yet. In states where popular (more so than Sinema) independents run and caucus with Dems, the DSCC stands down – Maine, Vermont. They don’t have to run a D and won’t want to if it looks like they’d only be a spoiler.

— David Weigel (@daveweigel) December 9, 2022

Sinema: independence ‘won’t change my work in Senate’

Kyrsten Sinema’s bombshell defection from the Democratic party will have far-reaching consequences as Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer attempts to plot a course through the upcoming Congress.

In her op-ed in the Arizona Republic on Friday announcing the move, the enigmatic Sinema sought to assure voters that “becoming an independent won’t change my work in the Senate; my service to Arizona remains the same”.

But the free-spirited politician, the first openly bisexual woman in the Senate, says she considers the bipartisan system in the US “broken” and won’t pledge her support to either party:

Americans are told that we have only two choices – Democrat or Republican – and that we must subscribe wholesale to policy views the parties hold, views that have been pulled further and further toward the extremes.

When politicians are more focused on denying the opposition party a victory than they are on improving Americans’ lives, the people who lose are everyday Americans.

Not that she fully supported the Democratic agenda in Joe Biden’s first two years in office, often teaming up with centrist West Virginia senator Joe Manchin to stall key parts of the president’s agenda.

Yet the statement will still alarm party leaders, who thought they had secured a 51-49 majority on Tuesday when Raphael Warnock won re-election in Georgia.

In a natural extension of my service since I was first elected to Congress, I have joined the growing numbers of Arizonans who reject party politics by declaring my independence from the broken partisan system in Washington and formally registering as an Arizona Independent. 1/3 pic.twitter.com/jUQHAeuxym

— Kyrsten Sinema (@kyrstensinema) December 9, 2022

Unlike Bernie Sanders (Vermont) and Angus King (Maine) who caucus with the Democrats, Sinema as an independent – unshackled by the Democratic party whip – will be an altogether different beast, whatever she says about her behavior not changing.

It’s not even clear she will retain her office on the Democratic side of the chamber. Or if she will re-election in 2024, something she says she won’t address yet.

It also restores “outsized influence in the Democratic caucus” to Manchin, according to Politico, which sat down for a 45-minute chat with Sinema this morning. Manchin was the main thorn in Biden’s side from within when the Senate was split 50-50.

We’re expecting to hear much more reaction today about the stunning news, including how Schumer intends to press on with committee assignments for the upcoming congress.

Read more:

Sinema leaves Democrats to become independent

Good morning and happy Friday! Democrats woke to a bombshell development from Arizona, where Senator Kyrsten Sinema has announced she is leaving the party and has registered as an independent.

The dramatic news comes just three days after Raphael Warnock’s re-election in Georgia gave the Democratic party what they thought was a 51-49 majority in the chamber (which includes the two other Senate independents Angus King of Maine, and Vermont’s Bernie Sanders).

The enigmatic Sinema’s defection will leave party chiefs scrambling to figure how, and indeed if, their new majority will work. While Sinema says she won’t caucus with Republicans, she says in a Friday op-ed in the Arizona Republic that the partisan system in the US is “broken”, and neither party can count on her support.

We’ll have plenty more news and reaction coming up.

Here’s what else we’re watching:

  • Freed basketball star Brittney Griner has landed back in the US from Russia. There’s political reaction to the prisoner-swap deal for a notorious Russian arms dealer.

  • We’re waiting to hear more from the House January 6 committee after reports emerged it was set to issue criminal referrals for Donald Trump insiders, including the former president himself.

  • White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre will brief reporters at 1pm. Joe Biden has no public events scheduled.

Leave a Comment